Worried About Airbnb Theft? Here Are 10 Simple Fixes to Protect Your Property

Marifil Limpahan
Nov 22
4 min read

How to Protect Your Airbnb: 10 Smart Security Tips Every Host Should Use

Running a short-term rental can be one of the fastest paths to financial freedom — but if you’ve ever worried about Airbnb theft, you’re not alone. Every host feels that little pinch of anxiety the first time they hand over access to their property.

The good news? Theft inside an Airbnb is extremely rare. But as Airbnb coaches and property managers who’ve helped dozens of hosts protect their rentals, we can confidently say this:

Strong systems prevent 99% of problems.

Below are ten simple, practical strategies you can use to protect your property, keep guests honest, and stay confident as you scale your Airbnb business.

Is Airbnb Theft Really a Problem?

Not really, but that doesn’t mean you should ignore it.

Airbnb reports that less than 1% of reservations result in any type of safety concern. Still, prevention matters because:

Financial loss hurts. Replacing items (or repairing damage) eats into your profits.
It’s emotionally draining. A violation of trust can make you question hosting altogether.
Your reputation matters. Negative reviews or conflict can impact your Airbnb SEO and overall Airbnb marketing.

At BNB Guardians, we always tell our coaching students:

“You can’t prevent everything, but you can prepare for everything.”

10 Tips to Prevent Airbnb Theft (BNB Guardians Approved)

1. Use a Keyless Smart Lock (And Change Codes Automatically)

Physical keys get copied, lost, or passed around. Smart locks eliminate that risk.

We use Guesty automations for every property we manage, it automatically generates unique access codes for every reservation and removes them after checkout. Zero manual work. Zero security risk.

This is one of the core Airbnb optimization systems we teach inside the Airbnb Super Host Academy.

2. Screen Guests Properly

Instant Book is convenient, but don’t skip vetting:

Look for verified ID
Read previous host reviews
Pay attention to vague messages or incomplete profiles
Communicate house rules clearly upfront

A quick message can tell you everything you need about a guest’s intentions and respect level.

3. Install a Security System (Outside Only)

Exterior cameras deter bad behavior and help verify who enters/exits.

Just make sure you:

Only place cameras outdoors
Disclose everything in your listing
Follow local laws

Smart alarms, door sensors, and outdoor lighting go a long way toward deterring opportunistic theft.

4. Store Your Valuables Securely

If something is expensive, sentimental, or irreplaceable, remove it from the short-term rental.

For items you cannot relocate:

Use locked closets
Install lockable cabinets
Provide a guest-friendly safe for their valuables

Less temptation = fewer problems.

5. Build Trust With Your Neighbors

Your neighbors can be your best defense system.

Your contact info
Check-in/check-out windows
What’s “normal” guest activity

A supportive neighbor will alert you if anything feels off long before it becomes an issue.

6. Inspect Your Property Regularly

Between every stay, make sure your cleaner or turnover assistant checks:

Doors & windows
Locks
Inventory
Electronics
Decor

At BNB Guardians, our Airbnb management team uses a detailed, itemized checklist to catch issues early, this is one of the easiest ways to prevent Airbnb theft or loss.

7. Set Clear House Rules

People follow structure. Make sure your rules include:

No unauthorized guests
No parties
Expectations around damages or missing items
Quiet hours

Send rules through Airbnb messaging, Guesty, and inside your house manual so guests see them multiple times.

8. Use a Rental Agreement When Needed

For longer stays, high-risk guests, or luxury properties, a rental agreement provides extra protection.

You can outline:

Consequences for theft
Replacement costs
Guest responsibilities
Liability details

This is a strategy we teach extensively in our Airbnb coaching program for hosts who want more peace of mind.

9. Get the Right Short-Term Rental Insurance

Traditional homeowners insurance usually doesn’t cover STR activity.

Instead, choose coverage that includes:

Theft
Property damage
Liability protection

Airbnb’s AirCover is helpful, but it’s not enough on its own. A dedicated STR policy closes the gap.

10. Keep Detailed Inventory Records

This is your best friend if something goes missing.

Record:

What’s inside the property
Serial numbers (for electronics)
Photo documentation
Notes after each turnover

If you ever need to file a claim, you’re ready.

What to Do If Theft Actually Happens

If something does go missing, follow these steps calmly:

1. File a police report immediately.

Document everything — time, missing items, evidence.

2. Contact Airbnb or your booking platform.

Submit all documentation through Airbnb’s Resolution Center.

3. Provide proof of value.

Receipts, photos, and inventory lists matter.

4. Escalate legally if necessary.

Small claims court is an option if you have clear evidence and Airbnb cannot resolve it.

Handling the situation quickly and professionally protects both your listing and your reputation.

Final Thoughts

Airbnb theft is uncommon, but smart hosts still prepare.With the right Airbnb strategy, systems, and tools like Guesty, you can protect your investment without stressing or micromanaging every guest.

If you implement the steps above, you’ll operate with more confidence, security, and peace of mind.